As the controversial killing of tigress Avni (code named T1) in the Indian state of Maharashtra kicked up a row, Women and Child Development Minister of India, Maneka Gandhi on 4 November 2018 accused Maharashtra Forest Minister Sudhir Mungantiwar of ordering the “ghastly murder” of a tiger and vowed legal action after the man-eating animal was shot dead.
The big cat blamed for killing more than a dozen people was shot dead on 2 November night after a months-long search, capping one of India’s most high-profile tiger hunts in decades.
But the shooting in the forests of Maharashtra state sparked immediate controversy and allegations the kill was unethical and illegal.
Gandhi, a staunch animal activist and part of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s cabinet, accused Mungantiwar of hiring a “trigger-happy shooter” to slay the tiger.
“It is nothing but a straight case of crime”, said Gandhi, a member of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), describing the shooting as a “ghastly murder”.
“I am definitely going to take up this case of utter lack of empathy for animals as a test case. Legally, criminally as well as politically,” she posted on Twitter.
She accused Mungantiwar – also from her party – of ignoring appeals to call off the hunt for the tiger known officially as T1 and popularly as Avni.
“It is nothing but a straight case of crime. Despite requests from his own forest department and people, Sudhir Mugantiwar gave orders for the killing. This is the third tiger being killed on his directions,” Gandhi said.
She said Mugantiwar earlier had ordered killing of a dozen leopards and 300 wild boars. “I am shocked that such a person is continuing to hold a ministerial position,” she said. “We cannot allow this kind of insensitive and merciless attitude towards animals to prevail. I am going to take up this issue legally, criminally as well as politically,” she added.
The Supreme Court had issued a hunting order for T1 in September, ruling that she could be killed if tranquilizers failed. Several appeals were made against the death sentence.
Forestry officials acknowledged to media that no vet was present during the hunt, as required by the Supreme Court order. The Indian branch of the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals said the tiger slaughter was about “satisfying a hunter’s lust for blood”.
The big cat was blamed for 13 deaths since June 2016 but animal activists said she was trying to protect her young. A team of more than 150 people had spent months searching for T1, using a paraglider and dozens of infrared cameras while sharpshooters had ridden on the backs of elephants.
T1 was shot by Asghar Ali Khan, son of India’s most famous hunter Nawab Shafath Ali Khan, who was meant to be leading the hunt but was not present on the night when tigress was killed. The senior Khan defended his son’s actions as “a reflex action of self-defense” as the tiger turned on the hunting party after being struck by a tranquilizer dart.
India has launched a major campaign to boost tiger numbers. At the last tiger census in 2014 the number had risen to more than 2,200 from a low of less than 1,500. But urban spread as the population of 1.25bn grows has increasingly eaten into the territory of wild animals. Endangered elephants and tigers kill on average one person a day, according to government figures. (Gulf Times)
Chief Minister of Maharashtra defends his minister
Maharashtra chief minister, Devendra Fadnavis, repeated Nawab Shafath Ali Khan’s statement while defending his minister. On 5 November he said, preliminary reports showed that the forest department team shot the tigress in “self-defense” after the team was attacked while trying to tranquilize the animal.
He also said any procedural lapse in the incident will be probed. “The forest department took the decision since she had killed 13-14 people. There are some doubts regarding whether the tigress was first shot and then the tranquilizing dart inserted, this aspect will be probed,” he said while talking to reporters in Mumbai. He also said that hunter Asghar Ali was hired by the forest department.
Asked to comment on Maneka Gandhi’s statement on the killing, Fadnavis said she had used “harsh words.” (Times of India)